Misidentification of Minerals
MISIDENTIFICATION OF MINERALS
by
Richard Drees
Not uncommonly, some soil-forming minerals will exhibit optical
properties that are apparently inconsistent with their crystal
form and structure; and inconsistent with properties listed above
and inmost reference texts. Such misalliance of characteristics
are due to one or a combination of factors:
- Strain or mechanical distortion of the crystal
structure which may produce birefringence in some isotropic
minerals and some uniaxial minerals to appear biaxial (e.g.,
quartz and calcite in metamorphic rocks).
- Variations in chemical composition. Depending on the
environment of formation, many minerals can have isomorphic
substitution of various elements in the crystall structure which
can alter the optical properties. This chemical variation is due
to the fact that structurally equivalent positions in the
crystallographic framework may be occupied by ions of different
elements. The ability of one ion to proxy for another is
governed by: a) ionic radii of the tow ions; b) temperature of
crystallization; and, c) crystal structure. Many minerals belong
to groups having a solid solution series between two end members,
making it often difficult to distinguish a particular member.
This effectis often observed by differences in color, change in
refractive index, an dtwinning pattern.
- Crystal size. Some mineral species can occur in such
fine-grained particles that aggregates appear isotropic (e.g.,
calcite in limestone, pedogenic carbonates, quartz in shale).
Most clay minerals are too small to identify in the petrographic
microscope.
- Color. Minerals that are colored (biotite, hornblend)
under plane-polarized light, will under cross-polarized light,
display interference tints that result from the combination of
the mineral color (due to absorption) and the interference color.
Thus, interference colors observed through the microscope may not
match the sequence of colors in the order listed in color
charts.
- In some twinned minerals (e.g., orthoclase) the grain may be
weathered such that only a single twin is observed. In such
instances, the determination of optic sign or interference figure
may be required for mineral identification.
- Alteration due to physical or chemical weathering.
Many minerals may be physically rounded during transport such
that crystal faces are no longer present. Chemical weathering
may obsure the identity of th eoriginal grain. However, the
evidence of physical or chemical weathering may provide useful
information.
- Some minerals may form pseudomorphs after other
minerals due to replacement. A pseudomorph is a crystal having
the outward form of another mineral, which is has replaced by
substitution. Examples include calcite or quartz after gypsum;
quartz may also form pseudomorphs after calcite.
- Artifacts in the thin section or grain mounts may look
like mineral material and show optical properties similar to
minerals. Artifacts include air bubbles, grinding powder, lint
fibers, some organic residues, and strained mounting resin which
may cause birefringence. Although not necessarily an artifact,
some minerals such as quartz may be fractured during sawing and
preparing a thin section. This may be due to poor preparation
techniques or using an old or imporperly cooled cutting blade.
Grain fracturing may look like physical or chemical weathering.

This page
(http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/plymouth/programs/minerals.html)
created by
Vera MacConnell,
Research Technician, I
on December 1, 1997.
Last Updated on December 8, 1997.