
Safe Mycotoxin Levels
Even with the best quality-control systems in the world, animal
producers often find themselves
owning mycotoxin-contaminated grain or feed. The question then
arises: "Is the level of
mycotoxin(s) present safe to feed to my animals?"
Prior to giving specific information, some general concepts
regarding the effect of mycotoxins on
animals must be understood. The determination as to whether or
not a given concentration of
mycotoxin is safe will depend on at least the factors which
follow (and there may also be other
factors).
- Chemical class and chemical structure of the mycotoxin in
question. A partial list of known
mycotoxins is shown in Table 1. The list includes mycotoxins from
a number of chemical classes,
each of which has different effects on the animals which consume
them. However, the exact
chemical structure of the mycotoxin involved is also vital. For
example, aflatoxin B1 is reported
to
be the most potent naturally occurring carcinogenic substance
known, but if just one chemical
bond is changed in the structure of the molecule, its toxicity
can be reduced dramatically.
- Presence of other mycotoxins. A number of studies have
demonstrated that mycotoxins
occur
simultaneously in field situations. This simultaneous occurrence
can profoundly affect the toxicity
of the mycotoxins present.
- Species and strain of the animals involved. Ducklings
are 5 to 15 times more sensitive to the
effects of aflatoxin than are laying hens, but when laying hen
strains are compared, certain strains
of hens may be as much as 3 times more sensitive than other
strains. This fact, along with the fact
that there is continuous genetic improvement of farm animals, can
mean that the exact sensitivity
of a given animal to one or more mycotoxins is unknown.
- Health status of the animals involved. Stress,
physiological state, nutritional standing, and
disease status will independently and collectively determine the
response of a given animal to a
specific mycotoxin level or complex of mycotoxins.
- Criteria by which effects are determined. At a given
dose, aflatoxin reduces weight gain in
growing animals, but disease resistance in the same animal may be
reduced by about half that
dose.
- Number of animals involved in judging the no effects
level. It has been estimated that
400 groups of 10 broilers would be required to detect a 1 percent
difference in growth rate. Yet,
in
integrated-poultry operations a 1 percent difference in growth
rate would have a significant
economic impact.
- Sampling and assay procedures. It is imperative that
sampling and assay procedures are
accurate, since the results are the basis for deciding whether or
not to use a given lot of feed or
feed ingredient.
- Length of time animals are exposed to the
mycotoxin(s). The exact mycotoxin tolerance
levels given elsewhere in this publication assume that animals
are exposed for a limited period.
Obviously, the risks of harm to animals from mycotoxins increase
as exposure time increases.
While the question of safe mycotoxin levels is a valid and vital
question, it is not an easily
answered question for the reasons just outlined. Perhaps the
shortest answer to the question is:
There is only one safe mycotoxin level...and that is zero.
However, a risk-free environment is
never
possible and background levels of mycotoxins are commonly found
in numerous feed ingredients.
In addition, no observable effects levels (NOEL) for mycotoxins
do not exist for each animal
species.
Table 1. A Partial List of Known Mycotoxins
Aflatoxins Fusaric Acid Penicillic Acid
Alternariol Fusariocin Penitrem
Citreoviridin Fusarins Phomopsin
Citrinin Islanditoxin Roridins
Cyclopiazonic Acid Luteoskyrin Rubratoxin
Deoxynivalenol Moniliformin Slaframine
Diacetoxyscirpenol Monoacetoxyscirpenol Sporidesmin
Dicoumarol Neosolaniol Stachbotryotoxins
Ergotamine Ochratoxins Sterigmatocystin
Ergo Toxins Oosporein T-2 Toxin
Fumitremorgen Paspalitrems Tremorgens
Fumonisins Patulin Zearalenone
Prepared by
Mary Beth Genter, Extension Toxicology Specialist
Winston M. Hagler, Director of NCSU Mycotoxin Laboratory
Jeff A. Hansen, Extension Animal Science Specialist
Bob A. Mowrey, Extension Animal Science Specialist
Frank T. Jones, Editor, Extension Poultry Science
Specialist
Matt H. Poore, Extension Animal Science Specialist
Lon W. Whitlow, Extension Animal Science Specialist
http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/gaston/