Focus on Balsam Woolly Adelgid

BWA bark The balsam woolly adelgid is an introduced pest that came into western NC in the early 1950s when the Christmas tree industry was just getting started. It used to be the most difficult to control pest of Fraser fir. This is no longer the case as most growers are getting BWA control with their scale control. However, if you don’t have either RBM or EHS, then BWA may be your worst problem.

Cultural Controls

Fraser fir is probably the true fir that is most sensitive to BWA attack. If BWA is present in your trees, you will almost certainly have to treat it with an insecticide. However, cultural controls can help you reduce BWA impacts and spread.

Fraser fir tree field near natural stand of trees

The natural stands of Roan
Mountain provide a source
of BWA crawlers

Avoiding Balsam Woolly Adelgid

If your Christmas trees are near natural stands of Fraser fir, abandoned or poorly managed Fraser fir stands, or yard trees of Fraser fir or any type of fir, they are more likely to get BWA. Whenever possible, remove large Fraser fir that cannot be treated for BWA from within site of your Christmas trees.

Avoid Excess Nitrogen

The BWA is another pest that is favored by excessive nitrogen applications. Pests often become more of a problem if the host plant receives excessive nitrogen fertilizer. That nutrition translates into nutrition for the pest, causing it to reproduce better. As many fields have a strong clover component in the ground covers which will supply nitrogen, the use of nitrogen fertilizer throughout the rotation is not needed. Not fertilizing younger trees with nitrogen may reduce problems with BWA in young trees.

Early Harvest or Culling

Heavily infested, badly damaged trees often will not recover even after treatment. Pesticide applications never result in 100% control, and these trees will only serve as a source of BWA to reinfest other trees. Trees that will never make a saleable Christmas tree should be cut down and burned. Remove trees that have not had a good top for two years. Do this when crawlers are not present unless you plan on treating the entire field soon afterwards. Otherwise you may spread crawlers to healthy trees when the infested ones are carried out of the field.

Some growers have managed to keep from treating a field for BWA by cutting out and removing infested trees. This can be a viable means of control depending on the cost of treatment and the number of infested trees.

When Chemical Control is Necessary

BWA can kill Fraser fir trees. BWA infested trees do not hold their needles well after harvest. The branches are also brittle, making it hard to bale trees. There are natural predators that feed on BWA such as Harmonia lady beetles, but these predators do not clean up the entire infestation. For these reasons, the presence of BWA always requires an insecticide treatment unless all trees will be harvested from a block of trees the year BWA is found. This is true even in organically grown Christmas trees.

Chemical Control of BWA

Traditional Control: High Pressure Sprayer

The best control of BWA is with a high pressure sprayer. Treat all surfaces of the tree including the trunk, branches, and foliage. The base of the trunk and under the trunk/branch unions are the hardest places to thoroughly wet, so be thorough. Treat trees from opposite directions. Do not try to treat more than 2 or 3 rows at a time. Butt-pruning trees and mowing tall weeds before treatment will improve spray efficiency. Also treat stumps of trees with live branches still attached. Adelgids will survive on cut stumps for several months.

Air-blast Mistblower Applications

Growers have been able to successfully treat for BWA with an air-blast mistblower. These types of application still require thorough coverage, so do not try to treat many rows at a time. Treat trees from opposite directions. Controls will be reduced in fields with tall weeds and/or heavy density trees.

Backpack Mistblower

For growers with limited acreage, treatments can be made with a backpack mistblower. Target all trees surfaces as with high pressure sprayer application. Treat trees from opposite directions.

BWA Chemicals That Work Any Time of Year

The following materials will control BWA any time of year. That is because they last long enough on the tree a month — the time it takes for all eggs to hatch to produce the crawler. However, the fall window is preferred as there is less impact on natural predators.

Pests Controlled	Treatment Description	Treatment Window
BWA BTA Cinara aphids EHS (plus Dimethoate from right before budbreak through early September)	ASANA or ASTRO: Will control BWA any time of year. Twig aphids will be controlled when these materials are applied from February through bud break. Fall applications of Asana or Astro will reduce twig aphid populations the following spring. Be sure to scout in the spring to determine the level of BTA control. Adding Dimethoate to Asana in the spring will also control EHS when applied right before budbreak through early September. (For more information about EHS control see: Focus on Elongate Hemlock Scale Control). Target treatments in fall or winter so as not to increase problems with mites. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.	Any time of year, fall or winter preferred
BWA BTA SSM Cinara aphids	SNIPER (or other bifenthrin product): Bifenthrin products include Talstar and Wisdom. Twig aphids will be controlled when applied any time of year though be sure to scout the following spring to make sure controls are sufficient. Target treatments in fall or winter so as not to increase problems with mites. These products will control SSM, but if HRM is also a problem consider adding an additional miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.
EHS BWA	SAFARI: As Safari is such a good systemic, applications with a mistblower should work better than other products. However, the longest lasting controls still require thorough coverage. Control of EHS with Safari is best from May through early September. Additional products must be added to control aphids or mites. For options see: Focus on Aphid Control and Focus on Mite Control.

Pests Controlled

Treatment Description

Treatment Window

BWA
BTA
Cinara aphids
EHS (plus Dimethoate from right before budbreak through early September)

ASANA or ASTRO: Will control BWA any time of year. Twig aphids will be controlled when these materials are applied from February through bud break. Fall applications of Asana or Astro will reduce twig aphid populations the following spring. Be sure to scout in the spring to determine the level of BTA control. Adding Dimethoate to Asana in the spring will also control EHS when applied right before budbreak through early September. (For more information about EHS control see: Focus on Elongate Hemlock Scale Control). Target treatments in fall or winter so as not to increase problems with mites. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.

Any time of year, fall or winter preferred

Fall

BWA
BTA
SSM
Cinara aphids

SNIPER (or other bifenthrin product): Bifenthrin products include Talstar and Wisdom. Twig aphids will be controlled when applied any time of year though be sure to scout the following spring to make sure controls are sufficient. Target treatments in fall or winter so as not to increase problems with mites. These products will control SSM, but if HRM is also a problem consider adding an additional miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.

EHS
BWA

SAFARI: As Safari is such a good systemic, applications with a mistblower should work better than other products. However, the longest lasting controls still require thorough coverage. Control of EHS with Safari is best from May through early September. Additional products must be added to control aphids or mites. For options see: Focus on Aphid Control and Focus on Mite Control.

BWA Materials that Work when Eggs Are Not Present

Pests Controlled	Treatment Description	Treatment Window
BWA BTA eggs (current year) HRM SSM eggs EHS (some control)	HORTICULTURAL OIL: A 2% horticultural oil solution will control BWA nymphs. Applying oil in mid-March will also control BTA for that spring, HRM, and give some control of SSM and EHS. For more information on the use of oil see: Organic Pest Control in Fraser Fir Christmas Trees.	Winter through mid-March
BWA BTA (current year) SSM (not eggs)	LORSBAN: Lorsban applied when BWA eggs are not present will provide good control. Applicaitons made from March through bud break will also control BTA in the spring. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.
BWA BTA	PROVADO (or other imidacloprid product): These products have not provided as long lasting control of BWA as other products. Applications made from March through budbreak will also control BTA in the spring. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.

Pests Controlled

Treatment Description

Treatment Window

BWA
BTA eggs (current year)
HRM
SSM eggs
EHS (some control)

HORTICULTURAL OIL: A 2% horticultural oil solution will control BWA nymphs. Applying oil in mid-March will also control BTA for that spring, HRM, and give some control of SSM and EHS. For more information on the use of oil see: Organic Pest Control in Fraser Fir Christmas Trees.

Winter through mid-March

dormant trees

BWA
BTA (current year)
SSM (not eggs)

LORSBAN: Lorsban applied when BWA eggs are not present will provide good control. Applicaitons made from March through bud break will also control BTA in the spring. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.

BWA
BTA

PROVADO (or other imidacloprid product): These products have not provided as long lasting control of BWA as other products. Applications made from March through budbreak will also control BTA in the spring. If mites are a problem, consider adding a miticide. For options see: Focus on Mite Control.

Additional Pest Focus Pages:

Focus on rosette bud mite control — If rosette bud mites are your problem, look no further for the control of all pests except Cinara aphids in market size trees.
Focus on elongate hemlock scale control — If you don't have rosette bud mites but do have elongate hemlock scale, look here for control of all your pests.
Focus on aphid control — Nearing harvest? RBM, EHS and BWA not a problem? Then the balsam twig aphid and Cinara aphids are your number one concern.
Focus on mite control — Mite control can be added on any time other pests are being controlled. Look here for added information on mite control.

Pest Control in Fraser Fir Christmas Trees