Construction Damage | Storm Damage | Lightning Damage | Snow/Ice Damage
Hollow Trees
| Water Stress | Damage to Tree Trunks


Many people purchase a house with large, existing shade trees expecting them to live forever. Other prospective home owners purchase a wooded lot with plans to build a new home among the trees. During the home construction process, however, many trees are destroyed or injured.

The damage that occurs during construction may not at first be obvious unless the tree's trunk was damaged. In most cases the tree appears healthy but produces little new growth. Stress symptoms caused by tree root damage may take 5 to 10 years to fully develop. The tree initially lives off of its stored reserves --- after the reserves are depleted and the tree is exposed to hot, dry weather the tree declines or dies rapidly. Often insects and disease will invade the weakened tree and lead to a gradual deterioration. During periods of stress (high temperatures and drought) the trees may go through a rapid decline and die.

Understanding the problem
Tree roots develop and survive where there is adequate oxygen and moisture. Most active tree roots are in the top 3 feet of soil; the majority are in the top 12 inches. The more compacted or poorly drained the soil the closer the roots are to the soil surface. Roots normally grow outward to about three times the branch spread. Only 50 percent of the trees root system occurs between the trunk and the dripline. Roots on one side of the tree normally supply the foliage on the same side of the tree. When the roots on one side of the tree are injured the branches on that side of the tree may die back or die. With some trees, such as maple, the effect may develop anywhere in the tree canopy.

You should decide which trees add value to the property and take necessary measures to protect them. Consider the location, species, size, age, and overall health. Will the tree provide needed shade in the summer? Is there too much shade to grow the plants you hope to install? Does the tree hide an undesirable view? Will roots pose a problem to sidewalks or driveway? Is it a high maintenance tree that will require frequent spraying for insect or disease control? Does it drop messy fruit pods or seeds? How adaptable is it to environmental changes?

Older trees do not adapt as well to changes in the environment as young trees. Some young trees may be replaced at a lower cost than trying to preserve them, especially if extensive treatment will be required to help them recover from construction damage. The length of annual twig growth and the size and color of leaves are indications of health and vigor. Examine the tree for dead wood and indication of decline.

Pre-construction care
Ideal, a tree protective plan is developed before construction begins. Many roots are destroyed when construction equipment pass over the root zone. Simply placing a barrier around the trunk of the tree does not protect most of the tree's root system. Place tall, conspicuous stakes and fencing at the ends of the branches on the sides where trucks or bulldozers will be operating. Groups of trees usually stand a better chance of survival than individual specimens.

Minimize construction traffic to a few paths which are covered with 6 to 10 inches of mulch and do not allow parking under desirable trees. Avoid storing construction material under trees. Do not store or spread soil beneath the canopy of trees which are to be saved. Be sure that grading changes do not cause water to be channeled towards the trees.

Root damage by trenching
Digging trenches for installation of water, sewer, telephone, cable, gas lines, or for building foundations can damage the root system of nearby trees. The percentage of the total root system affected, the overall health of the tree, time of year, and the type and age of the tree will influence the survival and recovery rate of the tree. To minimize potential damage, attempt to locate trenching in areas that will cause the fewest roots to be damaged or near areas that have already been trenched. If possible, designate one general area for trenching.

Roots covered by pavement
Roots which are covered by pavement may be deprived of air and moisture which are essential for growth. If the covered area involves only a small portion along one side of the tree, satisfactory growth should continue. If a large area around the tree is paved, the surface should be porous to allow water and air to penetrate. If brick or flagstone is used, joints should not be mortared. When pavement is nonporous, an opening should be left around the trunk of the tree. This opening should be at least 6 feet in diameter for small trees. The opening should be larger for mature trees unless the roots extend beyond the pavement into uncovered soil.

Changes in soil grade
Even a few inches of fill or soil removal can cause extensive root damage. If possible, never remove soil from or add large amounts of soil within the drip line. When soil air is decreased by filling, certain gases and chemicals increase and become toxic to roots. Symptoms may appear within months or years after filling has occurred.

The extent of injury from filling varies with the species, age, and condition of the tree; the depth and type of fill; and drainage. Beech, dogwood, most oaks, pine, sugar maple, spruce, tulip popular, and walnut are the most easily injured. Elm, locust, pin oak, sycamore, and willow are the least effected. Clay soils cause the most damage because the fineness of the soil shuts out air and water more than a gravelly or coarse soil. Three to four inches of soil can be added to small areas under the tree provided the soil texture is coarser than the native soil. Finer textured soils should not be used for filling.

If a tree well is to be constructed, built a wall no closer than the dripline and grade the soil outside of the tree well so it drains away from the tree. Success has been reported in some cases where gravel was spread over the existing grade and vertical pipes were installed every 10 feet before the area was covered with a coarse-textured fill soil. Building a tree well several feet from the trunk of a tree before adding several feet of soil will do little to prevent root death.


Care After Construction
Damage to the trunk
Bruised and peeled bark should be treated to promote rapid healing. Trim around the wound to sound tissue on each side. Use a sharp knife and do not cut any deeper than necessary. The top and bottom should be rounded instead of forming a sharp point. This will facilitate movement of moisture and nutrients around the damage area. When done properly, healing should occur completely around the wound.

If the damaged area is less than 25 percent of the circumference of the trunk, the wound should gradually heal over and no permanent injury should result. If the damage involves more than 50 percent of the circumference, the tree may be seriously reduced in vigor. It may lose branches and become quite unsightly. However, the corrective procedures of pruning, irrigation, and fertilization should be practiced until the tree recovers or until it is evident that the tree should be removed.

Damage from filling
The base of a tree at the soil line should flare out (be wider than the tree trunk a foot above the soil line). If the tree does not have a flare, but enters the ground in a straight line, fill dirt has been added. Digging will reveal the depth of the fill. Other visible symptoms include small leaves, many dead twigs, and the presence of numerous suckers along the main trunk and branches. If the filling was recently done and roots have not begun to regrow into the fill, efforts should be made to restore the soil to its original level.

Damage to roots
Damage to trees during construction usually involves impairment of the water and nutrient supply system. Therefore, three corrective procedures should be applied: thinning branches to reduce water requirements; irrigating as needed to maintain an adequate moisture supply, and applying fertilizer to help stimulate new root growth (avoid excessive nitrogen). Limited or no tilling should be done under damaged tree until they have had adequate time to recover.

A moderate application of fertilizer may be beneficial. Use 2 pounds of 5-10-5 per inch of trunk diameter measured three feet above the ground. Excessive applications of nitrogen will promote new foliage growth that the tree can not support with its reduced root system. The easiest and most practical method of application is to broadcast the fertilizer over the area of greatest concentration of feeder roots. These are located in a band around the tree starting about two feet from the trunk and extending several feet beyond the ends of the branches. Scatter fertilizer evenly over this area, and apply water liberally to wash it into the ground.

Keep the tree mulched and well watered during stress periods. Gradually prune and reshape the tree for balance and general appearance over a period of 3 to 5 years. Control devitalizing conditions such as sucker sprouts, insects, and diseases.

Storm Damage
Treatment of storm-damaged trees requires wise decisions and prompt action if the maximum benefit from repair work is to be achieved. Repairs come in two stages: first aid for immediate attention; and follow-up work to be distributed over a period of months to several years. Care for damaged large trees is best left to professionals.

First decide if the tree is worth saving. Does the tree serve a needed function or does it have sentimental or historical value? If over 30 to 50 percent of the main branches or trunk are severely split, broken, or mutilated, the benefit of extensive repairs is questionable. You probably would not want to save less desirable trees, such as black locust, Siberian elm, box elder, mulberry, poplars, and silver maple. More desirable trees, such as oak, maple, pecan, pine, magnolia, holly, and beech may be worth saving unless severely damaged. If the trees are close to power lines, building or other structures, the tree should be removed by a professional. Extremely old, low-vigor trees might not have the ability to recovery.

Small trees which are uprooted should be straightened and staked immediately. Left exposed to sun and wind will severely damage any upturned roots. Remove any damaged roots or branches. Some staking or cabling may be necessary.

Cut off broken and split branches but delay pruning to reshape the tree. Too much removal of wood in one season can create such problems as sunscald, weak branching habits, and sucker growth. Reattach trunk bark to the inner wood with galvanized nails if healing seems possible or trim the wound edges to promote healing. Promptly remove all debris such as broken branches and prunings to help eliminate breeding grounds for insects and diseases.

Lightning
Lightning strikes can cause various symptoms. They usually loosen bark which hangs in strips. The amount of bark loosened depends on the severity of the strike. The lightning bolt may have passed through the trunk and caused considerable internal wood damage that may not be visible. If only a small amount of damage occurred, remove damaged branches and loose bark and provide excellent cultural practices (mulch, water during drought, and fertilize). Damaged trees can die within a short period of time or years later following a period of stress.

Snow/ice damage
Snow and ice on branches can cause them to break or bend from the extra weight. High winds will compound the damage. The result is often misshapened plants from broken or split branches. Little can be done about removing ice from plants. Snow can be removed with a broom. Always sweep upward --- lifting snow off. When the branches are frozen they are quite brittle.

Do not be in a hurry to prune to correct plants bent out of shape by snow or ice. Often the plants will straighten up in a few days by itself. Broken branches, however, should be pruned as soon as possible. Proper pruning is effective in minimizing potential damage from ice and snow. Particularly important is the removal of weak, narrow-angled, v-shaped crotches.

Hollow Trees
Hollow trees result from a tree injury when Walls 1, 2, and 3 fail to stop the spread of decay. Fungi cause wood decay and insects assist with wood removal. Wall 4 remains intact so new growth continues to occur on the outer part of the trunk. The hollow portion of the tree will not exceed the diameter of the tree at the time of injury unless Wall 4 is damaged.

Traditionally, homeowners have attempted to clean decay from the cavity and to add a material, such as concrete, to fill the empty space. Cavity treatment is an exacting process that if done incorrectly can shorten the life of the tree. The hard rim of tissue, Wall 4, surrounding the decayed wood must not be broken or decay could spread to the wood produced after the initial injury. If you chose to remove decayed wood, only remove wood that comes out easily.

Benefits from filling the cavity are questionable at best. Since the fill material will expand and contract at a different rate than tree wood it can create problems of its own. The strength of a hollow tree comes from the new wood produced after the injury, not from material used to fill a cavity. Remove hollow trees that appear weak and are likely to fall.

Sometimes the cavity will contain water. The old recommendation was to drill holes below the cavity so the water could drain. However, drilling holes will break the barrier that keeps the decay from invading healthy wood. If water has been present for one or more growing seasons, the tree has already adjusted. You can cover hollow openings with a piece of tin or window screen filled with plaster to keep out animals, water, and to form a surface that allows new tissue to grow over the opening.

Water Stress
Most plants wilt when they experience inadequate moisture. Leaves on river birch and poplar trees turn yellow and drop. Sycamore leaves turn brown and fall, while other trees develop premature fall color or shed small branches.

A condition known as leaf scorch can develop on plants, such as dogwood, maple, beech, ash, and elm when their root systems can not replenish moisture as fast as it is lost from their foliage. This disorder can be caused by a limited or damaged root system, drought, and hot, windy conditions. The leaf tissue on the edges and between the main veins dies and turns brown. Eventually the entire leaf except for a narrow band along the veins die. Plants can be affected uniformly or only on one side. Plants growing near reflective surfaces such as roads and patios, as well as, recent transplants are more likely to be affected.

A similar condition can develop during the winter from desiccation. It is particularly important to provide relatively high soil moisture for evergreen plants prior to a severe freeze.

Damage to Tree Trunks

Bruised and peeled bark
Bruised and peeled bark should be treated to promote rapid healing. Trim around the wound to sound tissue on each side (Figure 1). Use a sharp knife and do cut any deeper than necessary. The top and bottom should be rounded instead of forming a sharp point. This will facilitate movement of moisture and nutrients around the damage area. When done properly, healing will occur completely around the wound.

If the damaged area is less than 25 percent of the circumference of the trunk, the wound should gradually heal over and no permanent injury should result. If the damage involves more than 50 percent of the circumference, the tree may be seriously reduced in vigor. It may lose branches and become quite unsightly. However, the corrective procedures of pruning, irrigation, and fertilization should be practiced until the tree recovers or until it is evident that the tree should be removed.


Lawn mower and weed-trimmer damage
Injury and infection started by a lawn mower or weed trimmer can seriously threaten a tree's health. The most severe injury occurs when the tree bark is slipping (loose due to cambium growth), in early spring during leaf emergence, and in early fall during leaf drop. The site of injury is usually the root buttress, since it flares out from the trunk and gets in the path of the mower or weed-trimmer. Although large wounds are more serious, repeated small wounds can also add up to trouble. Injury can be prevented by the removal (by hand trimming) or prevention (use of a herbicide or mulch) of grass and weeds from growing at the base of the tree.

Wounds are serious enough by themselves, but the wounded tree must also protect itself from pathogens that invade the wound. These microorganisms often attack the injured bark and invade adjacent healthy tissue, greatly enlarging the affected area. Trees can be completely girdled from microbial attack following injury. Decay fungi also become active on the wound surface, and structural deterioration of the woody tissues beneath the wound will often occur.


Prepared by: Erv Evans, Consumer Horticulturist, NC State University

© 2000 NC State University - All Rights Reserved