bST and Milk
John
E. Rushing and Don P. Wesen
Introduction
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) may soon approve the use of bovine
somatotropin (bST). When the product is injected into dairy cows they will
increase the production of milk.
Naturally produced by a cow's pituitary gland, bST is one of the hormones
involved in normal growth and development of the mammary gland and normal
milk production. Its presence in cow's milk is normal.
Since 1985, FDA has affirmed that milk from bST supplemented cows presents
no health risk to consumers. The hormone bST is a protein, not a steroid,
and is biologically inactive in humans. It is digested just like any other
protein in milk and food.
Milk is the principal source of minerals and protein required for the
growth of infants and children. The use of bST by dairy farmers to increase
milk production efficiency will not change the nutritional composition
of milk.
Old Compound, New Technology
For over fifty years scientists have known that injection of pituitary
extracts could increase milk production in lactating cows. However, development
of these extracts, later identified as bST, for dairy management purposes
was impractical. In the 1970's, the development of recombinant DNA technology
led to the volume production of certain important pharmaceuticals. Commercialization
of recombinantly produced human insulin, introduced in 1982, spurred the
development of other useful recombinant hormones. Among these hormones
were human somatotropin and bST.
By 1985, the FDA had determined that milk and meat from bST- supplemented
cows was safe for human consumption. As a result of their review of the
safety data, FDA informed Congress and authorized the sale of food products
from test cows. However, bST itself was not yet approved for public sale.
This approval has awaited extensive review of data from continued studies,
writing of draft regulations, and the final approval of the FDA Commissioner.
Increasing Milk Production
Cows genetically selected for higher production normally produce greater
amounts of bST. When cows are supplemented with increased amounts of bST,
the mammary gland takes in more nutrients from the bloodstream and synthesizes
more milk. This increase is accomplished by bST's effects on the synthesis
and secretion of insulin-like growth factors (IGF-I).To support this synthesis,
the cow voluntarily increases feed intake during the period of bST supplementation.
Since nutrient requirements for body maintenance remain virtually unchanged,
the result is an increased efficiency in the conversion of feed to milk.
Milk Composition
The effect of bST on the concentration of milk nutrients is dependent on
the nutritional status of the cows before and during bST supplementation.
Nutrients including fat, protein, and calcium are generally not affected
by bST administration. Fat, however, may vary somewhat in earlier stages
of supplementation. With the use of proper feed management practices, milk
production increases of about 10% may be expected.
Normal levels of bST in milk, about 10 ppb, are not significantly affected
by administration of the hormone to the cow. The modest rise of IGF-I concentration
is well within normal variation and at a level below its concentration
in human milk.
Human Safety Considerations
Early clinical researchers studying bST were hopeful of its usefulness
in treating human dwarfism. However, though the protein could be safely
injected into humans, it was not biologically active. Growth hormones are
species-specific. Since it is a protein hormone, it is digested by humans
into peptides and amino acids like any other protein. In fact, when presented
to a cow orally, bST is not active. The cow's digestive system simply recognizes
it as dietary protein.
Though the human safety of naturally-occurring bST had been established
in the 1950's, many more extensive studies were required by FDA prior to
the approval for marketing milk from test cows in 1985. Then, prior to
approving the marketing of recombinant bST in the U.S., many other issues,
such as animal health and labeling, had to be resolved.
Will Milk Be Labelled Differently?
There is presently no requirement for the dairy industry to label that
milk is from bST-supplemented cows. Labeling this milk would set a precedence
since this is not required of any other supplements. The safety of bST
is well established and tests on milk cannot distinguish between milks
from a supplemented and a nonsupplemented cow. Milk cannot be marketed
if it is from a cow which is receiving any veterinary therapy which might
produce a milk residue.
Animal Health Issues
Profitable milk production requires that cows are maintained in good health.
Scientists have found that the health of bST-supplemented cows is similar
to that of nonsupplemented cows producing similar amounts of milk. In any
case, good management practices by dairy farmers together with regulatory
monitoring of health and therapeutic treatments ensure quality milk for
the consumer.
Selected References
-NIH 1990. Bovine Somatotropin. Technology Assessment Conference Statement.
National Library of Medicine, Bethesda, MD 20892.
-Daughaday, W.H. and D.M. Barbano. 1990. Bovine Somatotropin Supplementation
of Dairy Cows. JAMA 264:8.
-Juskevich, J.C. and C.G. Guyen. 1990. Bovine Growth Hormone: Human
Food Safety Evaluation Science. 249 p. 875.
-FDA 1989. FDA Reviewing bST for Cows, Safety Data Being Published.
Talk Paper, FDA, Aug. 4, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, MD 20857.
-U.S. Congress OTA. 1991. U.S. Dairy Industry at a Crossroad: Biotechnology
and Policy Choices - Special Report. Office of Technology Assessment. OTA-F-470.
U.S. GPO. May 1991.
-CAST. 1993. CAST presents scientific information on Bovine Somatotropin
(bST). News Release, May 27, 1993. Council For Agricultural Science and
Technology, Ames, Iowa, 5 pgs.
Facts About Milk and bST
-
Dairy products are the most thoroughly tested and regulated products in
the food industry and are safe and wholesome.
-
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is likely to approve the use
of recombinant bST after years of exhaustive studies showing it is safe
for humans, animals, and the environment.
-
Published scientific research and reviews (appearing, for example, in the
Journal of the American Medical Association and Science) indicate that
milk from bST-supplemented cows is safe, and that the nutritional value
is unchanged.
-
Milk from cows receiving bST has the same amount of the protein as milk
from cows not receiving it.
-
bST is approved for use in many other countries, including Mexico.
-
bST is a naturally occurring protein, and is normally found in milk.
Distributed in furtherance of the Acts of Congress of May
8 and June 30, 1914. Employment and program opportunities are offered to
all people regardless of race, color, national origin, sex, age or disability.
North Carolina State University, North Carolina A & T State University,
U.S. Department of Agriculture, and local governments cooperating.
FOOD SAFETY FSE 93-1 [6-93]
Send comments to foodsafety@ncsu.edu
This page was last modified on