NOTE: This discussion applies to the use of termite baits in North Carolina.
If you live outside North Carolina, you should contact your State/County
Cooperative Extension Service Office, your state's land-grant
university or state regulatory
agency for local information concerning the availability
and use of these products.
Baits
are an important tool for termite prevention and control programs. Conventional
termite treatments for existing homes rely
primarily on soil-applied liquid termiticides. However, there are a number
of situations where a baiting system may be preferred over a liquid treatment,
used along with a liquid treatment, or it may be one of the few alternatives
to a liquid treaatment. For example:
- A liquid treatment
is considered too difficult:
- There
is a foundation drain around the house.
- Heating/air conditioning ducts are located under or in
a slab floor.
- A proper
treatment would require extensive drilling
of a slab that is covered by a wooden, tiled or carpeted floor,
or drilling through other masonry such as a finished basement
wall.
- A standard soil
treatment is illegal under federal, state and/or municipal regulations,
e.g., when there is a well or cistern under or near the house
- Liquid treatment
is considered unacceptable for whatever reason.
Which is the best method
of termite control?
Because liquid treatments and bait treatments are used (and work) very
differently, it is difficult to compare the two methods in terms of
which one works "better". The current soil-applied liquid termiticides
act essentially as chemical barriers to stop invading termites
and kill the ones that are actively infesting the structure.
Termites encounter these treated barriers during the course of their
normal underground foraging ("food hunting") activities.
The pyrethroid termiticides (e.g., Dragnet®, Demon TC®,
and Talstar®) primarily repel the termites. Other chemicals,
such as chlorpyrifos (Dursban® and other versions) simply kill
termites that contact the treated soil. The newer "non-repellent" termiticides
(such as Phantom®, Premise®, and Termidor®) kill termites
more slowly than the "older" chemicals after the insects come in
contact with the treated soil. Studies indicate that "contaminated" termites
may pass these non-repellent chemicals to other members of the colony,
which increases the overall impact of the termiticide.
With the baiting systems,
termites obviously must find and eat the bait in order
for the chemical to be effective. It
is important to realize that the current bait delivery systems (the
bait stations) and their contents generally do not "attract" termites,
although there has research and products development for possible attractants
that can be incorporated into these systems. Just as with baits used
for cockroaches, ants, and rodents, the termite bait stations contain
materials that the manufacturers have determined to be attractive food
resources for the termites. Laboratory studies have shown that some
of these materials appear to be "preferred"
or more attractive than the surrounding wood. Termites find the stations
during their normal foraging activities, just as they might
find any other underground food source. The acceptability of this "food" in
the station results in more termites coming to feed on it. There is
no way to predict how soon termites will find and feed in a bait station
so an important part of the baiting strategy is to install the stations
completely around the structure and to target known or suspected sites
of termite activity (e.g., near tree stumps). For that reason, a thorough
inspection of the house and immediate property is important before
the stations are installed. Also, weather may adversely affect termite
foraging. If the soil becomes very dry (for example, during
drought), termites may move further down or stay in surrounding moister
soils (such as in mulched or irrigated areas) and so they may enter the
stations less frequently.
Baiting is a long term, reduced-risk approach to termite control.
Unlike most conventional insecticides, the impact of termite baits is
not immediate. By design, the currently-used baits contain slower-acting
chemicals that may take several days or weeks to kill
individual termites depending upon the age of the termite and the type
of chemical in the bait. This delayed effect is crucial because it provides
time for the termites to carry the bait back to the colony and feed it
to other termites within the nest. As a result, it may take several months
before the entire colony is substantially reduced. The time of year will
also affect how quickly termite activity is eliminated. For example,
if the bait system is installed in the fall against an active infestation,
you might still see activity, including swarming (winged) termites in
the spring. This is particularly true for the bait products that contain insect
growth regulators (the
active ingredients in the Exterra, Advance TBS and Sentricon
systems) that do not directly affect the adult swarmers. However, this
same situation may occur even with a liquid treatment that is done very
late in the year (or in the winter).
The baiting
program continues year-round as long as you maintain your contract
with the pest control company. The
key to a successful termite baiting program is proper monitoring and
maintenance of the stations. Make sure you understand the monitoring/inspection
schedule followed by the company and that you receive regular updates
after every inspection, which may occur quarterly or monthly.
Possible Drawbacks to Termite Baiting Systems
This issue does not have a simple answer, but here are a few points to
consider:
Treatment Cost - the initial cost of the
baiting system may be higher than that for a liquid treatment.
Termite treatments, whether they're baits or liquids, are labor-intensive
and based largely on the dimensions of the house. The size ("footprint")
and complexity of the house's construction elements can affect both
baiting and liquid treatments in similar ways, e.g., larger
houses will require more soil-applied chemical or more bait stations
in order to do the job compared to a house with a smaller footprint.
However, the cost for a liquid treatment will be affected more significantly
by factors such as the type of construction. For example, since liquid
termiticides are applied to a vertical area of soil and must reach a
certain depth (4' or the top of the footer, whichever is less), a basement
house could cost as much as 4X more to treat compared to a crawlspace
or slab house of the same size depending on how deep (below grade) the
basement extends. Also, drilling and treating concrete slabs (e.g.,
garages, porches and patios) and masonry voids under state specifications
increases both labor and chemical costs. Click HERE
for details about treating for termites.
As noted earlier, in many instancesa house may not "treatable" with a liquid termiticide (e.g., wells
under the house) OR a liquid treatment may be difficult or environmentally
questionable. In these situations, the seemingly higher "cost" of a baiting
system must be weighed against its benefits in protecting you and the
environment.
Contract Maintenance - You can probably go anywhere on your
property and find termites, but that doesn't mean that they are constantly
attacking your house. It does mean that there is always a chance
that termites may find a way to invade the house. Although we expect
liquid termiticides to remain effective in the soil for at least 5
years (usually longer), this does not guarantee that termites will
not invade your house for 5 years. An annual inspection is the
only way to maintain that level of protection on your house. As with
the termite treatment itself, the cost of the annual renewal can be
affected by factors such as type of construction which can impact on
the extent of any post-treatment routine inspection. For example, certain
types of slab homes as well as homes with finished basements have far
less exposed areas where you might be able to detect termites when they
first invade the home. Pest control companies may
charge more for an annual contract simply because of the greater risk
(to them and to you) if they cannot detect termites in a timely manner.
It is somewhat similar to having higher medical insurance premiums because
of some previous health problems that make you a greater "risk" for
certain medical problems in the future. The
renewal for a baiting system contract is likely to cost 2x-4x more
than one for a liquid treatment because the bait stations
are typically checked at least four times per year ( more
frequently when termites actually attack a station) whereas houses
treated with a liquid soil treatment are inspected annually. With a
termite baiting system, if you discontinue your contract, then the
company usually removes the stations or simply stops servicing them.
Depending on when the house was last treated (and with what chemical),
there is a good chance that you are left with little, if any, chemical
protection against termites. You will likely need to have your house
retreated conventionally at some point. The bottom line is that termite baiting requires a
long-term commitment on your part. Take this point into consideration
when making your decision.
NOTE:
If you decide that you prefer the baiting system approach, make sure
that your contract specifies that the house is inspected annually. No
chemical termite treatment (liquid or bait) is going to be 100% effective
everytime, so an annual inspection of your house is critical.
Current
Termite Baiting Systems
The information presented here is not intended as an endorsement of one
bait product over another or for the use of the baits over liquid termiticides.
As with any termite control product, we recommend that you read all
available literature and make sure you understand how the product
works and what guarantee(s) the pest control company will provide to
protect your home from further termite attack and damage. All of
the currently approved termite bait products are registered for "standalone" use,
i.e., as the sole means of controlling the termites. However, a common
practice among pest control companies is to perform a liquid soil treatment
either to the immediate area of termite activity (i.e., a "spot" treatment)
or possibly to the entire exterior of the structure with the baits serving
as a monitoring/supplemental control component. Before
signing a contract for any termite treatment, make sure that
you understand what control methods will be used and to what extent
each is serving in protecting your home and the additional cost of
combined methods (versus the use of either a bait or liquid treatment
alone). Currently, there are five baiting/monitoring systems registered
in North Carolina for use by pest control professionals. These products
(listed alphabetically) are explained below. The mention here of specific
products is not as an endorsement of any one product over another or
of baiting being better or worse than a liquid treatment. The information
is here to provide you with basic understanding of termite baiting
and to allow you to pursue additional information before
making a decision on how to proceed in protecting your home.
- Advance™ Termite
Bait System (Whitmire-Microgen). Advance TBS is a
monitoring-baiting system. Inground stations are installed around
the structure. At the time of installation, the stations are pre-baited
with two levels: one a grooved cylinder of wood and the other a
Puri-Cell™ monitoring matrix. When termites are found in a station,
a termite bait cartridge containing the molt-inhibiting chemical
diflubenzuron is installed on top of the wood monitoring base.. Adult
termites, including reproductives and soldiers, are not affected
directly by this active ingredient. Immature worker termites which
do the foraging and food collection. Advance TBS can
be used as a standalone product although many companies employ
a liquid spot treatments of soil in the vicinity of known termite
activity. For information
about this product:
Web: http://www.advancetermitecontrol.com/whyhirepro.asp
- Exterra® Termite Interception
and Baiting System (Ensystex) - Exterra uses inground
monitoring-baiting system. When the stations are installed, they
contain only cellulose "interceptors". When termites are found feeding
on the interceptors in the station, the bait matrix is inserted into
the station's central cavity. The bait, Labyrinth®, is a cellulose-based
material that contains the chemical diflubenzuron, which interferes
with the molting process in immature termites. Adult termites, including
reproductives and soldiers, are not affected directly by this type of
chemical. Exterra can be used by itself, although localized
("spot")
treatments with liquid termiticides are often used when the stations
are installed. Exterra also has an aboveground baiting system that
can be where infestations are accessible within the structure. For
more information about the product:
Phone:
1-888-Exterra (398-3772)
Web: http://www.ensystex.com/
- Firstline® Termite Defense SystemSM
(FMC Corporation). Firstline also uses an inground monitoring-baiting
approach. Stations are installed around the structure, paying particular
attention to critical areas where termites may be more likely to be
active. When an inground monitor is attacked by termites, it is replaced
with the FirstLine® bait station, which uses a tube containing a cellulose-based
matrix impregnated with sulfluramid, a slow-acting stomach poison that
is also used in some ant bait products. An aboveground FirstLine® Termite
Bait Station can be used when termites are accessible within the structure.
Firstline can be used by itself, although localized ("spot")
with liquid termiticides are often used when the stations are installed.
For more information: Phone:
1-800-321-1FMC
Web: http://www.pestsolutions.fmc.com/Pest_Solutions/GeneralDetail/0%2C1668%2C1936%2C00.html
- Sentricon Colony Elimination System® (Dow AgroSciences). Sentricon is a monitoring-baiting
system. Inground stations are installed around a structure at
specific intervals (not exceeding 20 feet). At the time of their
installation, the stations contain cellulose monitoring devices
only. When termites are found in the station, they are transferred
to a bait tube which is then inserted into the station in place
of the monitoring devices. The bait, Recruit® IV , contains
a cellulose-based matrix that is impregnated with noviflumuron,
which interferes with the insect's ability to molt. Adult termites, including reproductives and soldiers,
are not affected directly by this type of chemical. An
aboveground station, Recruit®IV AG, is used in conjunction
with the inground stations when termites are directly accessible
within the structure. Sentricon is labeled for use by
itself, although some companies may use a "spot" liquid treatment
at sites of known termite activity. For information about this
product: Phone: 1-800-686-6200
Web: http://www.Sentricon.com/
- Subterfuge Termite Bait®
(BASF) - Unlike the other professional baiting
systems which initially use wood or other cellulose monitoring devices,
Subterfuge stations are installed with the termite bait from
the start. The active ingredient in Subterfuge is hydramethylnon,
a stomach poison which is also commonly used in ant and cockroach baits.
According the manufacturer, the active ingredient is incorporated into
a "preferred" feeding substrate, i.e., a food material which termites
prefer over wood (and other cellulose-based materials). As a result,
the termites consume more of the active ingredient which is carried
back and potentially distributed to other members of the colony.
Subterfuge can be used as a standalone product although many
companies employ a liquid spot treatments of soil in the vicinity of
known termite activity. For information about this product:
Web: http://www.pestcontrolfacts.com/products/subterfuge/
Consumer
Bait Products -
Terminate® (Spectracide)
is a termite bait product available to consumers. The active ingredient
in the bait is sulfluramid ,the same active ingredient used in the
professional product Firstline.
While Terminate is readily available to the
general public in most areas of the country, please bear in mind
a few important points mentioned on the product label:
- The product label
states that you must replace ALL of the stakes after 12 months.
Before disposing of these old stakes or any unused stakes, you need
to check with your local waste management office about the proper
disposal to make sure that you can legally (and safely) discard them
with your household trash. In some cases, you may be required to
take the items to a municipal or private hazardous materials disposal
site.
- Terminate is not intended
as a sole protection of your house against termites.
- If you have an active infestation, you should get a professional
inspection
IN CONCLUSION
If a professional inspection of your home confirms the presence
of termites, some sort of corrective measure is strongly recommended.
Your efforts and monetary expenditures are probably best spent on getting
the best possible professional service that you can find. Termite
control, whether it is through the use of soil-applied liquids,
bait products, or other recognized mechanical methods is best performed
by a trained and licensed professionals.
|