Gardening Note #7
SOIL AMENDMENTS FOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY
Soil Amendments
Why? Simply, plants can't breathe in clay.
The actual need is to amend AERATION of soil rather than soil
itself. Clay has plenty of particles and water but not oxygen
pore space. Red clay has excellent potential; amending aeration
makes it good soil. The gray plastic of Cumberland County is
among
the world's worst soils.
How? By incorporating into the soil organic
materials that will maintain oxygen pore space. The best method:
put down a 2" layer, turn them into the soil, add another 2",
turn
them in, etc. Incorporate any necessary nutrients when tilling
in
the amendment material.
Amount: 2 - 2 1/2" of amendment material
per 8" of soil. 35% by volume is ideal. The minimum is 25%,
maximum is 50%; less than 10% will not provide sufficient
aeration.
When to amend: When planting
annual/perennial beds, shrubs, vegetables, ground covers, herbs,
etc. Ideally the amendment material is added in the fall, tilled
in, and allowed to overwinter.
Trees: While there is not universal
agreement on the subject, most of the experts in this area
recommend NOT amending the soil when planting trees since the
roots must ultimately grow in our native soil. They do recommend
loosening the soil by digging or tilling an area 3-5 times the
size of the root ball, adding any necessary nutrients or lime,
and backfilling with the native soil. A 3-4" mulch will conserve
moisture and discourage weeds. See Planting Trees and Shrubs.
Soil Amendment Materials Not
Recommended:
- Peat Moss: If it dries, it repels water; if wet,
it retains water. Clay already retains water for us. An added
reason for not using peat moss is that peat is not a readily
renewable resource. Bogs can be revegetated but it takes nature
almost 5000 years to return the bog to its original state. Peat
moss is acceptable for sandy soils and for house plants.
- Sand: You need at least 70% sand to 30% clay, and it
is still not a good idea. The tiny clay particles fill in the
spaces between the larger sand particles, making a readily
compactable material. Add a bit of water and make your own
parking lot.
- Anything freshly shredded: Until thoroughly
decomposed, everything will deplete the nitrogen supply, to the
detriment of plants.
Recommended materials:
- Pine Bark is probably the most practical material that
is readily available for homeowners. Pine bark is a native
material. An ideal size grind of pine bark (@ 1/4" to 1/2") is
now available at most garden supply places as "Pine Bark Soil
Conditioner." There are other products on the market called
"soil conditioner" but many are too fine to provide the needed
pore space. The
most desirable size is about that of a
flattened pea. Truckloads are available also; look in
yellow pages under "Soils."
- Leaf Mold, aged vs composted leaf mold: The city's
leaf pile is simply "aged" whereas compost has oxygen and
nitrogen added. The Carbon/Nitrogen ratio of dry leaves is 90:1
(vs the desirable ratio for compost of 30:1), which means the
nitrogen will come from the soil unless you add supplementary
nitrogen. Freshly ground leaves are not a good soil
amendment/conditioner if you want to plant immediately but they
are fine if turned into the soil and overwintered with
supplementary nitrogen.
- Compost: The perfect soil amendment,
non-nitrogen-depleting, nutrient-providing, soil
structure-improving, but few homeowners have it in quantities
needed to amend a heavy clay soil.
- Humus: Humus is partly- to thoroughly-decomposed
vegetable matter. A superb soil amendment but it is usually not
available in quantities needed except by truckload.
- Pea Gravel: #78, 3/8" diameter gravel is esthetically
horrendous but it does work. It is a permanent soil addition,
doesn't break down. Your grandchildren will continue to profit
from it, though your tiller won't.
- "Topsoil": "Topsoil" is often an unknown quantity and
is offered in many formulations. Often it contains too much
sand, and it may contain many weed seeds. Putting down a layer
of a different soil on top of clay will encourage root growth in
that top layer only. Roots will not penetrate the clay layer,
decreasing survival chances of plants when under stress
conditions. Use of "topsoil" depends on what is being planted in
the area. It is fine for raised beds but for most other uses it
should be incorporated into existing soil down to the level of
the anticipated root area.
"Maybe" Group: Organic Senior Citizens only
- Sawdust: If very old and supplemented with nitrogen,
sawdust is a good soil amendment. It has a 400:1 CARBON/NITROGEN
ratio and will harm plants without supplementary nitrogen.
- Hardwood chips: May raise soil pH undesirably,
depending on type and amount used. Requires nitrogen supplement
and regular pH checks if used. They break down faster than pine
chips. Must be aged before use.
- Wood chips from tree-cutting crews: Must be aged one
to several years, depending on content of load. View them as
having fairly distant future use only: composition is usually
unknown, they often have 1-3' shreds or pieces of logs, and the
CARBON/NITROGEN ratio can be 800:1, meaning a very high nitrogen
supplement is essential.
- Manure well aged manure is an excellent soil amendment
material that provides some minor nutrients as well, but its
fertilizing capacity is often over-estimated. Most analyze at
about 1-1-1. Some examples:
| |
N | P | K |
| Cow manure, dried
| 1.3 | 0.9 | 0.8 |
| Chicken manure, fresh
| 1.1 | 0.9 | 0.5 |
| Horse manure, fresh
| 0.6 | 0.3 | 0.5 |
RULE OF THUMB
The optimum CARBON/NITROGEN ratio is 30:1 but
few of us can achieve this state of perfection. A very
rough rule of thumb is: 1-2 cups Nitrogen per
bushel of organic matter. Remember that
organic matter requires oxygen to decompose (the
reason compost piles need to be turned
often) so breakdown time will depend on nitrogen
supplementation + oxygen availability +
temperature.
This information compiled by Cumberland County
Master
Gardeners.
This page was created on 4/20/98 using the Durham Master Gardener
Homepage as a model. Our thanks to them and especially to
Pauline Marx, Pam Reading and Eileen Lowenbach.
Revised on 05/07/98.