Gardening Q&A December 15, 2002

garden
tools
GARDENING Q&A
by Rett Davis
garden
tools

Gardening Q&A by Rett Davis appears in Alamance County's daily newspaper, The Times-News, every Sunday in the Accent section. Each week's installment is posted to this website, beginning with January of this year. Scroll to the bottom of this page to navigate to other Gardening Q&As. Please contact Rett via e-mail with questions or comments in regard to this column.

December 15, 2002

It has been a long time since the Piedmont of North Carolina has witnessed an ice storm. Growing up in this area I can remember many over the years. Many of our worst ice storms have been in the sandhills of this state and the southern Piedmont. I can remember seeing entire pine forests torn to shreds. I can still lead you to a farm where there are abandoned chicken houses pulled to the ground by the weight of ice.

Ice storms have a way of making us pay attention to trees. Even more so than hurricanes and tornadoes. Our love affair with trees is often ended after a storm like last week, Our friends become foes. Is there anyway to prevent such a disruption in our lives and prevent this from happening again?

Over my entire career (29 years plus) I have taught classes, workshops, and made countless visits teaching professionals and homeowners proper tree care. Trees need periodic checkups just like humans. So much of what I have seen over the past week could have been prevented if we had been more diligent in our efforts to keep trees healthy.

I have seen dead tops of trees fall out onto power lines. These dead tops where never removed from the last storm. I have seen trees split down the middle because they had two double leaders or codominate stems. Many trees split at points in the tree that were decayed. Other trees just fell over because they were leaning before the storm which is the case for many pines. I could go on and on. The point is that a lot of damage could have been prevented.

Some species of trees are more prone to damage naturally. Examples would be Bradford pears and river birch. Unfortunately the Bradford pears had not shed their leaves in time adding additional weight they could not bear. In the past most of our ice storms come later in the season.

This is not to say that we can prevent all damage from trees. Even the healthiest and strongest trees will break and they did. But as caretakers of these plants we can do a lot better job of storm proofing them. Remove the questionable ones, keep them free of deadwood, prune limbs off of roofs, and don't plant them under or near power lines. Regardless of how much you love your trees, they will not love you back.

Question:
I have several cedars that are bent double form the ice. Should I stake them to straighten them up?

Answer:
Cedars and other conifers that have strong bends in them will straighten up naturally. As long as they did not uproot they will be fine.

Question:
I have an elm tree that lost a very large limb. Almost half of the tree is gone and it tore one side of the trunk down about 3 feet. Can it be saved?

Answer:
Large tears such as this will not heal. Uneven surfaces will not allow callus tissue to form. In just a few years the wood will begin to decay causing further problems. In addition the weight of the tree is not evenly distributed. Remove the tree.

Question:
There are a lot of little limbs and branches broken in the top of our willow oak. Because they are so high up and small should I still get someone to cut them out?

Answer:
Small broken limbs in tops of trees will require the use of a bucket truck to reach them. I would not worry about small limbs or a few breaks. In many cases bucket trucks just cannot get into areas to even reach them. If the tree has other limbs that need to come out or deadwood removed, then it may be worth the effort to get them.

Question:
I have a leyland cypress that fell over and is laying on the ground. It is almost 12 feet tall. My husband wants to pull it back up and tie it to stakes. Will this save the tree?

Answer:
A large tree like this has too many broken and damage roots. It will only fall over again in years to come. Put it on the street.

Question:
Several of my crapemyrtles have broken trunks that have split. How is the best way to prune this?

Answer:
If a majority of the trunks are split, then prune all the trunks back to a point below the break. Make your pruning cuts so that all the trunks are the same height. Therefore the size of the tree will be determined by the lowest split.

Question:
We have several river birches at work in which almost all the tops have broken, bent over, and are touching the ground. Should we try to save this tree by pruning?

Answer:
If a majority of the trunks have snapped and have fallen over I would seriously consider taking the tree down. River birches are prone to this type of damage. I don't find them to be a very desirable landscape tree. For trees with minor damage, just prune the trees below the break. They will be fine until the next storm.


Continue to the next installment

Gardening Q&A Navigation Options

  • Gardening Q&A Archives - previous installments since January 2001

    If you have any horticultural questions, please direct them to Rett Davis